diff --git a/cura/Machines/MaterialNode.py b/cura/Machines/MaterialNode.py
index 18db7d982d..179451ff67 100644
--- a/cura/Machines/MaterialNode.py
+++ b/cura/Machines/MaterialNode.py
@@ -31,6 +31,7 @@ class MaterialNode(ContainerNode):
         my_metadata = container_registry.findContainersMetadata(id = container_id)[0]
         self.base_file = my_metadata["base_file"]
         self.material_type = my_metadata["material"]
+        self.brand = my_metadata["brand"]
         self.guid = my_metadata["GUID"]
         self._loadAll()
         container_registry.containerRemoved.connect(self._onRemoved)
@@ -80,6 +81,7 @@ class MaterialNode(ContainerNode):
                 # such as "generic_pla_ultimaker_s5_AA_0.4". So we search with the "base_file" which is the material_root_id.
             else:
                 qualities = container_registry.findInstanceContainersMetadata(type = "quality", definition = self.variant.machine.quality_definition, material = self.base_file)
+
             if not qualities:
                 my_material_type = self.material_type
                 if self.variant.machine.has_variants:
@@ -89,9 +91,22 @@ class MaterialNode(ContainerNode):
                 else:
                     qualities_any_material = container_registry.findInstanceContainersMetadata(type = "quality", definition = self.variant.machine.quality_definition)
 
-                all_material_base_files = {material_metadata["base_file"] for material_metadata in container_registry.findInstanceContainersMetadata(type = "material", material = my_material_type)}
+                # First we attempt to find materials that have the same brand but not the right color
+                all_material_base_files_right_brand = {material_metadata["base_file"] for material_metadata in container_registry.findInstanceContainersMetadata(type = "material", material = my_material_type, brand = self.brand)}
 
-                qualities.extend((quality for quality in qualities_any_material if quality.get("material") in all_material_base_files))
+                right_brand_no_color_qualities = [quality for quality in qualities_any_material if quality.get("material") in all_material_base_files_right_brand]
+
+                if right_brand_no_color_qualities:
+                    # We found qualties for materials with the right brand but not with the right color. Use those.
+                    qualities.extend(right_brand_no_color_qualities)
+                else:
+                    # Fall back to generic
+                    all_material_base_files = {material_metadata["base_file"] for material_metadata in
+                                               container_registry.findInstanceContainersMetadata(type="material",
+                                                                                                 material=my_material_type)}
+                    no_brand_no_color_qualities = (quality for quality in qualities_any_material if
+                                                   quality.get("material") in all_material_base_files)
+                    qualities.extend(no_brand_no_color_qualities)
 
                 if not qualities:  # No quality profiles found. Go by GUID then.
                     my_guid = self.guid